The 2025 NFL Draft was expected to be a coronation for Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders—a projected first-round pick with a Heisman-worthy résumé. Instead, it became a cautionary tale. Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, plummeted to the fifth round, selected 144th overall by the Cleveland Browns. This unexpected slide has ignited debates among fans and analysts alike. (Sanders ‘unprecedented’ draft slide captivates pundits, Ward shines as first pick, Fans plot NFL merchandise boycott after Shedeur Sanders $40m draft slide – and it could make him millions)
The Resume: Why Sanders Deserved Better
Sanders’ college statistics were nothing short of stellar. In 2024, he completed 74% of his passes for 4,134 yards, 37 touchdowns, and only 10 interceptions, setting multiple school records at Colorado. His performance was even more impressive considering he played behind one of the nation’s weakest offensive lines, which allowed 56 sacks. Despite constant pressure, Sanders demonstrated exceptional poise, accuracy, and decision-making. His adjusted accuracy percentage of 81.8% ranked second among FBS quarterbacks, and he had one of the lowest turnover-worthy play rates at 1.2%. (2025 NFL Draft Scouting Report: Shedeur Sanders – WalterFootball, Why Shedeur Sanders projects as a top-5 pick and QB1 in the 2025 NFL Draft – CBSSports.com, Shedeur Sanders 2025 NFL Draft Scouting Report)
The Slide: Unpacking the Reasons
So, why did a quarterback with such credentials fall to the fifth round? Several factors have been cited:
- Lack of Elite Physical Traits: Some scouts questioned Sanders’ athleticism and arm strength, suggesting he lacked a “superpower” trait that sets top-tier quarterbacks apart. (‘Where’s the Superpower?’ – NFL Insider Reveals Why Shedeur Sanders’ Stock Is Slipping Ahead of 2025 NFL Draft)
- Pocket Awareness: Critics pointed to his tendency to hold onto the ball too long, leading to unnecessary sacks and hits. (Shedeur Sanders Will Not Be a First Round Pick in the 2025 NFL Draft | The Wright Way Network)
- Perceived Attitude Issues: Reports indicated that some teams were concerned about Sanders’ demeanor during pre-draft interviews, viewing him as arrogant or entitled.
- Family Influence: The prominent presence of his father, Deion Sanders, in the pre-draft process may have raised concerns about potential distractions or complications.
The Aftermath: A Family’s Response
Despite the disappointment, the Sanders family remained supportive. Shedeur hosted a star-studded draft party in Dallas, celebrating with friends, family, and celebrities. His mother, Pilar Sanders, posted a heartfelt message on social media, expressing pride in her son’s achievement. (Shedeur Sanders’ mom posts heartfelt message after dramatic NFL draft, Inside Shedeur Sanders’ star-studded NFL draft 2025 afterparty with Kodak Black, Yung Miami and more)
The Fan Reaction: Outrage and Support
Fans were quick to express their frustration over Sanders’ draft position. Some initiated a boycott of official NFL merchandise bearing his name, choosing instead to support his personal brand. This grassroots movement could potentially offset the financial implications of his lower draft slot.
The Future: A Chip on His Shoulder
Now a member of the Cleveland Browns, Sanders joins a crowded quarterback room that includes Deshaun Watson, Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, and third-round pick Dillon Gabriel. Despite the competition, Sanders has an opportunity to prove his doubters wrong and carve out a successful NFL career. (‘Why do they look forced into it?’ – Fans spot Cleveland Browns’ front office’s reaction to drafting Shedeur Sanders)
What do you think, fans? Why did Shedeur Sanders fall to the fifth round? Was it justified, or did teams miss out on a potential star? Share your thoughts in the comments below.